Thinking of planting that “For Sale” sign and heading for warmer pastures? Before you start picking out floor plans for a Florida condo, you might want to put down the packing tape. In the Garden State, leaving isn’t as simple as a handshake and a moving truck. Between the “Exit Tax,” a shifting “Mansion Tax,” and the questionable status of the state’s budget, the math on moving has changed:
NJ’s Beloved Senior Freeze and STAY NJ:
For years, the best reason to stay in NJ has been the Senior Freeze (Property Tax Reimbursement). It “freezes” your property taxes at the level of your first year of eligibility. If you’ve lived here for 20 years, you’re likely paying thousands less than your neighbor who just moved in. If you sell, that rate disappears—you can’t take it with you. [1]
Then there’s STAY NJ. This program promised to cut property taxes in half for many seniors (up to a $6,500 credit). The catch? You have to actually stay. If you sell now, you’re walking away from the most aggressive property tax relief in state history. [2]
Devil’s Advocate: Can NJ Afford to Keep These Programs?
NJ has a habit of making big promises when the coffers are full and “adjusting” them when things get tight. While STAY NJ launched with fanfare, current 2026 budget discussions already include proposals to cut the STAY NJ benefit to address a structural deficit. [3] If you are staying only for the tax breaks, keep in mind that what the State House giveth, the State House can taketh away during the next budget crisis.
Murphy’s Solution: The Mansion Tax Shift.
Traditionally, the 1% fee on home sales over $1 million was the buyer’s headache. Not anymore. Under legislation signed by Governor Murphy, the responsibility has shifted to the seller. Furthermore, the rate is no longer a flat fee. For sales over $2M, the rate climbs—hitting 2.5% for homes over $2.5M. [4] Selling a $2.6M home? Prepare to hand over $65,000 just for this one fee.
The Exit Tax
The NJ Exit Tax is technically a “pre-payment of estimated tax,” but to a seller, it feels like a ransom. If you move out of state, NJ typically withholds 2% of the total sales price of your home at closing to ensure they get their cut before you cross the bridge. [5] While you may get some of this back after filing your non-resident return the following year, it remains a significant hit to your immediate moving liquidity.
The $500,000 Exclusion Limit
If you’ve lived in your home for at least two of the last five years, you likely know about the federal capital gains exclusion: $250,000 for individuals and $500,000 for married couples. However, NJ’s real estate market has been on a tear. If you bought your home for $300k in the 90s and it’s now worth $1.2 million, you have a $900k gain. After your exclusion, you still have $400k in taxable profit. At NJ’s top income tax brackets (which can hit 10.75%), that “happily ever after” check starts looking a lot smaller. [6]
Be Smart – Don’t D.I.Y. Your Exit
Before you sign a contract, you need to crunch the numbers with a professional. Between the tiered Mansion Tax, the capital gains hit, and the potential for disappearing rebates, the grass may not be greener on the other side.
Consult your Financial Planner today. We can help you calculate the “Net to Seller” after NJ takes its piece.
Sources:
[1] NJ Division of Taxation. “Senior Freeze (Property Tax Reimbursement) Eligibility Requirements.” (February 2026) https://www.nj.gov/treasury/taxation/ptr/index.shtml
[2] NJ Department of the Treasury. “Stay NJ Property Tax Relief Program – Senior Homeowner Reimbursement.” (March 2026) https://www.nj.gov/treasury/taxation/staynj/index.shtml
[3] NJ Spotlight News. “State Budget Crisis 2026: Proposed Cuts to Property Tax Relief Programs.” (April 2026). NJ Spotlight News: April 20, 2026 | Video | NJ Spotlight News
[4] NJ Realtors®. “Graduated Percent Fee (GPF) Update – Impact of P.L. 2025, c. 69.” (July 2025) https://www.njrealtor.com/government-affairs/realty-transfer-fee/
[5] NJ Division of Taxation. “GIT/REP Requirements: Estimated Tax Withholding for Non-Resident Sellers.” (May 2025) https://www.nj.gov/treasury/taxation/njit11.shtml
[6] NJ Division of Taxation. “Income Tax: Sale of a Principal Residence and Capital Gains Exclusion Limits.” (May 2025) https://www.nj.gov/treasury/taxation/njit10.shtml
Disclosure:
Advisory services are offered through Millstone Financial Group Limited Liability Company, a Securities and Exchange Commission Registered Investment Advisor located in the State of New Jersey. Insurance products and services are offered through Millstone Financial Group Limited Liability Company. Millstone Financial Group is not affiliated with or endorsed by the Social Security Administration or any other government agency.
All material discussed is for informational purposes only. Opinions expressed are solely those of Millstone Financial Group Limited Liability Company and staff. All topics covered are believed to be from reliable sources; however, Millstone Financial Group Limited Liability Company makes no representations as to its accuracy or completeness. Investing involves risk including the loss of principal.
This article shall in no way be construed as a solicitation to sell securities or investment advisory services to residents of any state other than New Jersey, or where otherwise permitted. All information and ideas should be discussed in detail with your individual adviser prior to implementation.
Millstone Financial Group Limited Liability Company dba Millstone Financial Group does not offer tax planning or legal services but may provide references to tax services or legal providers. This material is intended to provide general financial education and is not written or intended as tax or legal advice. Individuals are encouraged to seek advice from their own tax or legal counsel. Millstone Financial Group may also work with your attorney or independent tax or legal counsel. Please consult a qualified professional for assistance with these matters. You should always consult with a qualified professional before making any tax or legal decisions.
